Retirement Planning 9 min read

Why Investors Earn Less Than Their Own Funds, and How a Wealth Manager Helps

Why Investors Earn Less Than Their Own Funds, and How a Wealth Manager Helps
Prudhvi Raj
Senior Financial Analyst

Get data-backed market insights

Well-researched articles on markets, equities, mutual funds and investing, delivered to your inbox.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Vinca Wealth. Unsubscribe anytime.

Do you Need a wealth Manager?

Two people can buy the same mutual fund on the same day, and one of them can end up with far less money than the other. The fund didn’t change. The investor’s behaviour did.

If a friend has told you to get a wealth manager, the question in your mind is probably simple: what can a person do for me that apps, YouTube and free advice can’t? Information is not the problem. We have more of it than any generation before us. The real problem is what we do with it when markets are exciting or frightening.

This article looks at what Indian investors actually did over the last two years, using data from AMFI (the mutual fund industry body), and shows where a good wealth manager makes a real difference. It also shows where one doesn’t.

1. We buy what has just gone up

In 2025, domestic gold prices rose about 75% and silver about 168%. Investors noticed. Gold ETF inflows in FY26 reached a record ₹68,867 crore, in a category whose yearly inflows had earlier ranged between ₹700 crore and ₹15,000 crore. In January 2026 alone, ₹24,039 crore went into gold ETFs and ₹9,463 crore into silver ETFs, together more than the ₹24,029 crore that went into all equity funds that month. In five months, gold ETF accounts grew from about 80 lakh to 1.14 crore, and silver ETF accounts from 11 lakh to 48 lakh.

Then the excitement cooled. Gold ETF inflows fell to ₹5,255 crore in February and ₹2,266 crore in March. In May, they recorded their largest monthly outflow on record.

Small-cap funds followed the same script a little earlier. Money poured in through the 2023–24 rally. In March 2024, after the market regulator warned about “froth” and fund houses were forced to cap new investments, small-cap funds saw their first monthly outflow in 30 months. The crowd that arrived because prices were rising left when the news turned uncomfortable.

And today? In September 2026, small-cap and mid-cap funds took 44% of all equity inflows (₹16,873 crore out of ₹38,307 crore), even though small caps were trading at a 34% premium to large companies, against a 10-year average discount of 11%.

Asset What happened to the price Where the crowd arrived What followed
Gold Up about 75% in 2025 Record ₹68,867 crore into gold ETFs in FY26 Inflows fell from ₹24,040 crore (Jan 2026) to ₹2,266 crore (Mar 2026)
Silver Up about 168% in 2025 Silver ETF accounts rose about 4x in five months Inflows cooled sharply after January
Small caps Strong run in 2023–24 Record inflows, then SEBI’s froth warning First outflow in 30 months (Mar 2024)

To be clear, this is not a case against gold or small caps. Both have a place in a portfolio. The point is the pattern: most people decide after a big rise, when the asset is already expensive and the news is loudest. A wealth manager’s job is to ask “how much of this does your plan need?” before the headlines ask “are you missing out?”

2. We start strong and stop when it gets uncomfortable

A SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) is meant to be the cure for bad timing: invest a fixed amount every month and stop worrying about the market. The industry tracks one number that shows how well that idea survives real life, called the SIP stoppage ratio. In plain words, it compares how many SIPs were closed or completed in a month with how many new ones were started.

In October 2026, about 59 lakh SIPs were closed or completed, while only 51 lakh were started. The ratio was about 116%. In September it was 78.5%, and it has hovered between roughly 75% and 90% for most of the last year.

A fair caution: this number includes SIPs that finished their planned term, so it is not the same as “this share of investors panicked”. Analysts say the same. But it still shows a pattern: in a typical month, for every 100 new SIPs, 75 to 90 others end. Record monthly contributions (₹32,490 crore in September 2026) hide a lot of churn underneath.

There is another data point worth knowing. According to the AMFI-Crisil Factbook 2026, 34.4% of SIP money invested through regular plans (the route where a distributor or adviser is involved) had been running for more than five years. For direct plans, where investors act on their own, the figure was 19.9%. This does not prove that advice alone causes the difference, since the two groups of investors are not identical. But it is consistent with a simple idea: people stay the course more often when someone is there to talk to them on a bad day.

Why does this matter? Because a SIP works precisely because it keeps buying when prices fall. Stopping during a fall removes the cheap units that do most of the work when the market recovers.

3. What this behaviour costs

India does not publish a standard measure for this, but the world’s most followed study does. Morningstar’s Mind the Gap 2026 compared what US funds returned with what their investors actually earned, after accounting for when investors bought and sold. Over the 10 years to December 2025, investors earned about 1.2 percentage points less per year than the funds they owned, roughly 12% of the total return.

Two details stand out:

  • The gap was widest for the most volatile funds (about 2.1 points) and narrowest for the calmest ones (about 0.4 points). The bumpier the ride, the more people jump off.
  • Investors in diversified allocation funds kept about 92% of their funds’ returns, and US stock fund investors about 97%. Crypto-linked ETFs showed a gap of roughly 14 points a year.

This is US data, and Morningstar itself notes that part of any gap can come from sensible habits like investing every month. Still, see what 1.2 points can do. Illustration only, not a forecast: ₹10 lakh growing at 12% a year for 20 years becomes about ₹96 lakh. At 10.8%, it becomes about ₹78 lakh. The same fund, the same 20 years, and about ₹18 lakh lost to timing.

Are you on track for financial freedom?

Find your retirement corpus, your gap and your projected retirement date in 2 minutes. Free.

4. What real crashes look like

Every long-term investor in India will face a fall like these. The two biggest in modern history:

2008 Global Financial Crisis 2020 COVID crash
Nifty 50 fall About 60% (6,357 to 2,524), Jan to Oct 2008 About 38% (12,430 to 7,610), Jan to 23 Mar 2020
Time to fall About 10 months About 2 months
Time to regain old high Roughly 5 years About 8 months (Nov 2020)
What buyers near the bottom saw About 118% gain within 2 years The index went on to rise about 200% over 3.5 years

Someone who stayed invested through all of 2020 ended the year about 16% up on the Sensex, despite the crash in March. Someone who sold in March locked in the loss and missed the recovery.

Here is the uncomfortable truth: on 23 March 2020, almost nobody felt like holding on. Fear is not a character flaw. It is how people are wired. That is why the best protection is a plan made calmly, beforehand, and a person who reminds you of it when you’re not calm.

On a day like that, a good wealth manager does a few specific things. They call you before you press “sell”. They check that money you need within three years was never in equities to begin with. They remind you what you agreed in writing. And if your plan allows, they rebalance, buying equity from what has fallen so that you benefit when it recovers.

5. Why asset allocation is the real job

If you remember one idea from this article, make it this one: nobody knows which asset will lead next year, and the leader keeps changing.

Look at the recent past. In 2025, gold rose about 75% and silver 168%, the Sensex gained about 10% by November, and the Nifty Smallcap 250 slipped about 5%. Then, in the year to September 2026, the Nifty 50 fell 7.1%, while the Nifty Midcap 150 gained 4.6% and the Nifty Smallcap 250 gained 7.2%. An investor chasing last year’s winner would have been wrong-footed twice.

Asset allocation is the answer to this. It means deciding in advance, based on your goals and time horizon, how much goes into equity, debt, gold and other assets, and then rebalancing when markets pull things out of line. Think of a cricket team. You would not pick eleven batsmen because batting was the best performer last season. You build a balanced side and trust it across conditions.

Rebalancing also quietly forces the opposite of chasing: trimming what has run up and adding to what has lagged. It feels wrong each time you do it. That is exactly why most people don’t do it alone.

6. What a wealth manager does, and what they don’t

What they do: define your goals and timelines (child’s education, retirement, a home); assess how much risk you can genuinely handle; build and maintain the asset allocation; rebalance; review taxes, insurance and emergency funds; and, most importantly, act as the steady voice when you want to react.

What they don’t do: predict markets, guarantee returns, or protect you from every fall. Be careful with anyone who promises any of these.

Do you need one? Ask yourself three honest questions. Have you never stopped a SIP out of nervousness? Have you never bought something mainly because it was rising or a friend was buying it? Do you have a written plan with target allocations? If you can say yes to all three, you may manage well alone. Most people cannot, and that is not a weakness. It is the reason this profession exists.

How to choose one: check that the adviser is SEBI-registered, and ask whether they are a registered investment adviser or a distributor. Ask how they are paid (fees, commissions, or both) and whether that could influence what they recommend. Ask for a written plan that explains why each investment is there. Avoid anyone who leads with product names instead of your goals.

Not sure how you would behave in the next fall?

A short conversation can show you where you stand today. At Vinca Wealth, we review your current investments, compare your allocation with your actual goals, and point out where behaviour or concentration may be quietly costing you. There is no obligation and no jargon.

Disclaimer: Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully. Past performance is not indicative of future results. This article is for education only and is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any product.

Book Your Free Consultation on Mutual Funds Today

Explore the Mutual fund options and identify the mistakes you are doing

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Vinca Wealth registered?

Yes. Vinca Wealth is an AMFI registered mutual fund distributor (ARN-293401), based in Bengaluru, Karnataka. Our company CIN is U65999KA2022PTC169569, and our Insurance POSP Code is 1726204591.

Do I have to pay Vinca Wealth any fee?

No. We don’t charge you a fee for planning or investing. As a mutual fund distributor, we receive a commission from the fund houses whose schemes you invest in, and we disclose this upfront. You invest directly from your bank account to the fund house; your money never passes through Vinca Wealth.

How can I find out if I’m on track for retirement?

Start with our free Financial Freedom Calculator on vincawealth.com. In about 2 minutes it estimates your retirement corpus, your gap and your projected retirement date. You can then book a one-on-one session with our team to build a goal-based plan.

Can I meet the Vinca Wealth team?

Yes. We meet clients one-on-one at our office in Bengaluru or at a place of your choice in Bengaluru. If you live in another city or outside India, we connect over a video call.

About the Author

Prudhvi Raj

Senior Financial Analyst

15+ Years of Experience In the Wealth Management Industry.